A legal analysis on the alignment of Cariom port states with international instruments to combat illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing

Date of Award

9-16-2026

Document Type

Thesis

Degree Name

Doctor of Philosophy in Maritime Affairs

Abstract

Illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing is a serious threat to global fisheries sustainability, marine biodiversity, and the food security of coastal-dependent populations. Beyond acknowledging the development of binding and voluntary international instruments to prevent, deter and eliminate IUU fishing, assessing the alignment of these frameworks in domestic legal regimes is especially critical for states with limited capacity. As such, the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) emerges as an important yet underrepresented region of small island developing states (SIDS). Using a doctrinal legal analysis, this research assesses the extent of alignment between key provisions of international instruments to combat IUU fishing at the port state level and the fisheries legislation of CARICOM member states. The port state is the central point of analysis utilized herein, as all catch must be landed for a sale, which makes ports the critical point at which illicit fishing activity can be effectively and cost- efficiently intercepted. Additionally, this research proceeds from the recognition that law is the foundation for proper enforcement; without which, enforcement efforts risk being unlawful, ineffective or unstandardized. In assessing the legislative foundation systematically, an original scorecard was created from a compilation of binding and voluntary provisions of international instruments, against which the national Fisheries Acts of 13 English-speaking CARICOM member states are evaluated. Importantly, the research’s analysis is not concerned with whether CARICOM states have formally ratified any particular international instrument. Instead, international instruments provide a benchmark that is applied diagnostically, rather than as an accountability standard. The findings reveal a regionally consistent pattern of legislative asymmetry. Approximately 65% alignment is recorded across the region, with respect to the provision of general monitoring, control and surveillance (MCS) measures for fisheries conservation and management. However, alignment stands at approximately 31%, when assessed against the foundational legislative provisions required to formally recognize IUU fishing and address it through effective penal mechanisms. When assessed against the key port state obligations that constitute the operational core of the international port state measures framework, alignment stands at approximately 26%. This disparity between general fisheries governance and IUU-specific legislative capacity is the central finding of this research. It indicates a significant area for legislative reform and development across the region, which no degree of operational effort, partnership or political commitment can adequately address in the absence of a legal foundation. Beyond the core legislative analysis, this research situates its findings within the broader governance and political economy of IUU fishing, via four papers included in this research. The first paper examines what effective PSMA implementation requires of Caribbean states, with regard to legal, human resource and financial capacity needs, finding that the principal barrier is not political will but operational capacity, and that legislative implementation is the essential and distinct step that ratification alone does not accomplish. The second paper examines transshipment as a mechanism through which legislative gaps may be exploited by IUU fishing actors, finding that the exclusion of carrier and reefer vessels from the definition of fishing vessels in several CARICOM Fisheries Acts creates a critical regulatory gap through which IUU catch may enter ports undetected. The third paper examines public-private partnerships as a capacity-building mechanism, finding that such partnerships present a viable and underutilized instrument for designing, operationalizing and enforcing legislative reform, and producing an original alignment guideline for CARICOM states. The fourth paper examines fisheries subsidies as a structural economic driver of IUU fishing, finding that

capacity-enhancing subsidies sustain the profitability of IUU fishing in environments of legislative underdevelopment, and proposing a compliance-conditioned model that ties state financial support to verified adherence to applicable fisheries management measures. Together, these findings reinforce the research’s central conclusion that the fisheries laws of CARICOM member states reflect a documented and regionally consistent disparity with relevant international instruments, and that this disparity can be addressed through targeted legislative reform that facilitates greater alignment between national laws and international instruments to combat IUU fishing.

This document is currently not available here.

Share

COinS